From where I sit, here's where most people are, including President Donald Trump: George Floyd's killing was wrong, and justice should be meted out as swiftly as possible, within our system, on the cops who killed him. No angry mob should have a say in this and the cops should be given no special deference simply because they are cops.
We've all seen the video of Floyd's death, and though the criminal justice system has some bad actors, it is the system we have, and we must trust it to handle this situation appropriately.
At the same time, it is not contradictory to believe that we cannot tolerate violent riots and the destruction that has been taking place in parts of American cities night after night. When the President says he wants both justice for Mr. Floyd and a restoration of law and order, I believe him. If it takes a deployment of the US military to do it, because governors and mayors cannot get control of the situation in their jurisdictions, I think the President will find public support for it.
It is likely that a national poll would find the American people want rioting to stop and that they trust the military to make that happen (whether that's the right policy choice, I don't know, and the Secretary of Defense, Mark Esper, threw cold water on the idea Wednesday in a news conference).
I also suspect that a national poll would find that Americans have strong sympathies both for the small business owners who have seen their livelihoods ruined and for the vast majority of police officers who are good actors and just as disgusted by the Floyd killing as you or me.
At the same time, the President cannot govern this situation by photo-op.
I was not sure what to make of his march to St. John's Church across Lafayette Square as I watched it unfold live on Monday. I wish he could have taken one step further and stepped into the church and opened the Bible he held. I wish he had invited faith and civil rights leaders to go there with him. And I wish he would have sat in the front row for a church service aimed at praying for peace, calm and unity.
Churches and Bibles are not props; they are tools for the faithful to spread the Word of God and to unify people around God's teachings. And churches, perhaps more than any other place, can be powerful places from which to broadcast expressions of sympathy and calm.
Finally, there's one other thing boiling below the surface that has receded somewhat in media reports during the coverage of demonstrations but is a point of agitation for America's rule-following public: Covid-19 restrictions.
After being scolded for months to stay inside, after watching some mothers and their kids chased from parks by police, after watching 40 million Americans lose their jobs, after doing everything their government leaders told them to do, Americans are seeing, day after day on their TV screens, thousands of people disregard all social distancing orders as they protest and riot in the streets.
A version of this story is playing out across America. The worst Covid-19 scolds -- mostly Democratic governors and mayors and their supporters -- are silent as executive decrees on shutdowns are disregarded.
One governor, Kentucky's Andy Beshear, even laughably commended the protesters, in a statement, "for largely following CDC guidelines to prevent the spread of Covid-19," which was not at all what his constituents were seeing on their TV screens as they watched the crowds swell.
If the danger was true last week, why isn't it true today? Is there something special about the Floyd demonstrations and subsequent riots that makes protesters immune from Covid-19? If only self-righteousness could immunize us from disease!
So here we are. A nation torn up about George Floyd, with too many of us still wondering why grotesque acts like these keep happening. A nation torn up by coronavirus, wondering why many demonstrators can flout lockdown orders but people who wanted to go to church, go to work and send their kids to school were forbidden for months.
A nation torn up by its leadership, whipsawed by the contradictions, the dumb tweets, and the twin images of peaceful protesters and violent rioters.
Where public opinion settles out in all of this, I don't know. But it seems like there's too much churn in the water to simply divide America into two corners -- red and blue -- these days.